A nervous election night in Nanaimo
Synopsis
Nervous energy filled the Vancouver Island Conference Centre Saturday night as Nanaimo's local election results were revealed.
Mayor Leonard Krog won re-election, although by narrower margins than in the 2022 and 2018 elections, beating challenger Sarah Lovegrove by 1907 votes. Andréa Coutu and Marnie Boers joined six incumbent candidates on council, while incumbent Janice Perrino fell just short of re-election. The only slate running, REAL Nanaimo did not see a candidate elected for mayor or council, although REAL council candidate Sandy Bartlett was the second runner up, just behind Perrino.
Midcoast Morning takes you to the scene of Nanaimo's local election results reveal, and brings reaction from those in the race.
Transcript
Editor's Note: Transcripts are lightly edited for style, ie: filler words, stutter-starts, and repeated words have been removed. Report transcription errors by emailing production@chly.ca.
–Transcript Start–
Announcer: The following is a project of our nonprofit newsroom. Support Midcoast Morning and local journalism today at chly.ca/donate. Local news doesn't survive without local support.
–
Joe Pugh: Hello and welcome to Midcoast Morning. I'm Joe Pugh. Nervous energy filled the Vancouver Island Conference Center Saturday night, as dozens of candidates gathered in one spot to learn the outcome of Nanaimo's local election. In the end, an election that saw 44 candidates seeking one of nine seats on Nanaimo City Council brought two new faces, alongside seven returnees.
Though the margin was tighter than in 2022, Mayor Leonard Krog won reelection with close to 10,400 votes, ahead of nearest challenger Sarah Lovegrove, who received around 8,500 votes. Andréa Coutu and Marnie Boers were elected to council, joining six incumbents. Incumbent Janice Perrino fell one place short of retaining her seat, around 1,400 votes behind Ian Thorpe, who claimed the final spot on council.
The top vote getter was Ben Geselbracht, who was one vote shy of 12,400. Members of the CHLY newsroom were present Saturday night as results were being unveiled poll by poll. Today on the program, we'll take you into the room and bring reaction from those elected to Nanaimo's next council. Heading into his third term, Mayor Leonard Krog expressed surprise at the election results.
Ian Holmes (Nanaimo News Now: What's your initial reaction to you being reelected in office and, and the council that's been selected?
Leonard Krog: Look, obviously I'm very pleased to be reelected. I would be less than honest if I didn't say I'm disappointed by the numbers and the percentages. I find it surprising. Nanaimo's clearly taken, I think, a fairly green turn, , in terms of the voting patterns, and we'll see what the implications of that are for the council over the next four years.
Holmes: What kind of message do you think this sends to you? Your support's obviously eroded here.
Krog: Yes. Yes.
Holmes: Len, you, you sound somewhat humbled. Expand on what you think led to this, this?
Krog: Well, I– look, I've always said it's an honour and a privilege to do the job, and am I humbled? I don't think I was that arrogant before, so, , I wouldn't use the term humbled. But I will say it's going to be, , strategically more challenging, I think for council and the city generally, but we'll see what happens. I'm very interested to watch the results across the province tonight as well because there are implications, I think, here for the upcoming provincial election as well on the 24th.
Skye Ryan (CHEK): Can you speak to that? What do you mean, implications?
Krog: I think there's clearly a desire for change, and that is never good for any sitting government. Whether that plays out or not, it's hard to say. I haven't heard any results from Vancouver, and I'd be intrigued to hear what they are, but the last thing I heard, former Mayor McCallum was leading in Surrey, for heaven's sakes.
Ryan: Wow, and Adam Walker in Qualicum Beach.
Krog: Adam Walker knocked off Tunnis Westbroek, who is very popular, well-liked, long-term mayor, and from my perspective, a very good mayor.
Holmes: Len, and just the, the new makeup of council here with, Marnie and Andréa are new–
Krog: Yes.
Holmes: –faces and Janice is out.
Krog: Yeah.
Holmes: Just, just what do you think this- It looks- You, you said, you know, a more of a leftist sort of leaning feel to it. What does this mean for the next four years in terms of what you think can be accomplished by this council? I know it's fresh, but what do you think about it?
Krog: Well, I think we're going to see, quote unquote, more money spent on environmental issues, than would have normally been the case.
Whether or not there'll be the kind of emphasis on necessary infrastructure when it comes to rezonings, I think it has implications for industrial lands, which most people seem to acknowledge we need more of, otherwise the residential tax base will continue to pay the substantial portion of the city's expenses.
I have been very clear about that. We need more industrial land.
Holmes: Right. And, just for the next number of years with these huge infrastructure priorities, the RCMP building, the public works, South End Community Centre, $150 to $200 million, maybe the Departure Bay walkway. There's, over the next like five to ten years, there's some massive infrastructure needs …
How are you guys gonna sort of navigate your way through that, with the challenges you're outlining here?
Krog: Look, the, the good news is that Nanaimo is in a very good position in terms of its ability to borrow money, and in terms of what we spend on debt servicing, whether it be, both principal and interest, we're in a very good position compared to other municipalities.
We're spending about, I think it's 12 cents out of the dollar we could spend. But will there be an appetite for those kinds of projects? That's an interesting question.
Holmes: Mm-hmm.
Krog: I mean, I don't know the new, potentially two new councillors very well. We'll see what their position is.
Certainly we'll engage in the usual education process both at the regional district, and at the City of Nanaimo, so that people will get some understanding of what their role is as councillors, which is important. I mean, I understand my role as mayor. The councillors who have been reelected certainly understand their role.
But we'll see how the two new ones fit in.
Julie Chadwick (Time Colonist): Are you surprised, Krog?
Krog: Yes. I am surprised.
Chadwick: Yeah?
Krog: Yeah.
Chadwick: What are you surprised about?
Krog: I'm surprised about the results. I mean, I thought that I would do better. I'm surprised that Councillor Perino's not going to be on council. Councillor Perino brought both experience as the former mayor of Summerland, , and enthusiasm and a background at the Nanaimo Hospital Foundation, and the leadership on the Regional Health District Board, which I think was very important for us helping secure the commitments from the provincial government.
So yes, I mean, I'm surprised.
Chadwick: And what about the, performance of Sarah Lovegrove [the] new [mayoral] candidate?
Krog: Very surprising! Very high! She obviously ran a very effective campaign and/or people got tired of me!
Chadwick: [Chuckle]
Jesse Woodward: Krog, we also saw organized slates running–
Leonard Krog: Yes, yes
Woodward: –broadly in opposition of the sitting council as well as, I suppose, yourself. How do you respond to them not making it on the board today?
Leonard Krog: Well, I was confident that anyone who ran on a slate, a formal slate, wouldn't get elected. But I don't think there's much question either that the first top three vote getters ran a sort of informal slate to some extent, and I don't say that critically, but I think it's pretty obvious, and that had an impact, clearly.
—
Joe Pugh: Challenger Sarah Lovegrove didn't win the race for mayor, but saw positives from the election results.
—
Sarah Lovegrove: I see this as a big win for the people in Nanaimo. I think this speaks volumes, as to the desire for change. When I look at what's in front of me, I see far more people who voted against the person who won than voted for, and I think that's a remarkable fact that our community is speaking out against what has been happening for the last eight years and that desire for change.
Karl Yu (Nanaimo Bulletin): Talk about that change. What would you like to see change?
Lovegrove: I mean, I ran because I wanna see more compassionate leadership. I want to see evidence-based interventions for our city's biggest problems. We have– we are at an incredible moment in time where our community is facing multiple complex intersecting crises that are killing people every single day.
And the person who just won for the next four years is refusing to look at the evidence and what the experts are telling us to do in terms of responding to that crisis, those crises. And I am-
Ryan (CHEK): So you said crises there, right?
Lovegrove: –Crises, yes. Okay. Multiple crises, yes. Housing, toxic drug crisis, mental health, et cetera.
We need to be doing more. We need to be looking at evidence. I'm hopeful about some of the councillors that have come on, both incumbent and new, in terms of what they're potentially gonna move forward. But I fear, around the leadership, the tone, the culture of our city and our … city staff, in terms of nothing changing in the next four years.
Yu: What can you do going forward? Can you, I guess, continue to advocate, and that sort of thing, right?
Lovegrove: Yeah, I mean, my work is not gonna end here. I think this provides me with a larger platform and a more, robust capacity to advocate on behalf of our community. I've now heard from, people across this community, their support, their enthusiasm, their desire for change, their desire to listen to evidence, and that motivates me further.
… When I entered into this race, I did so for the purpose of bringing forward these, these crises, having these conversations, making sure that there is accountability at le- in the, in the seat of leadership. And, to disrupt this process to make sure that we know what's actually happening in our community and what can be done.
And I feel as though I've accomplished that in this process.
Mick Sweetman: Do you feel like, you know, having this first election under your belt, that, you know, you may be participating in future ones?
Lovegrove: I think there's a lot of potential in politics for creating that important change, and I'm open to whatever's next.
Sweetman: What are the lessons maybe that you learned from your campaign?
Lovegrove: I think all the lessons that I've learned have been positive. I think I have learned how important it is to work with people who are most impacted in this community. My entire campaign was funded by people on disability, people on low income, giving me $10, $20, $30, $40 donations at a time.
We accomplished what no one has been able to accomplish before in terms of, competing against Leonard Krog.
Yu: Any thought to running on any [other] levels of government? Obviously not provincial, but, maybe federal, maybe-
Lovegrove: I'm open to, to whatever's next, and I'm willing to take that– take that ride in whatever direction it takes me.
Sweetman: So one of the things we saw here, and, obviously it happens quite a lot in Vancouver, is the slate, running together as official slates. Do you feel like there's a need for a progressive slate such as we see in other cities?
Lovegrove: I think Nanaimo's a very, small and unique community, and I don't think–
I ultimately don't think that slates are appropriate in this community. I think there was a number of kinds of lists put together in terms of progressive candidates, and I'm seeing a lot of those successful right now in terms of council, which I'm hopeful about. I'm not sure if it would be effective or not, to come together as a slate in that process.
Yung : Hindsight being 20/20, maybe, do you think maybe, maybe running as a councillor might've been, , a different route you should've taken or anything like that? Or are you happy that you ran for the mayoral position?
Lovegrove: I'm happy that I ran for the mayoral position simply because of the intense dilution of the number of council candidates.
I don't think my platform and the issues that I was trying to bring forward would've gotten the same attention if I was a council candidate, and that was the ultimate goal here. I wanted to make sure people were talking about the toxic drug crisis. I wanted to make sure people [were] talking about housing and the actual interventions that we could utilize in our community, and now our community knows.
They know what the answers are. They know what the solutions are, and they can join the advocacy that I'm gonna be moving forward.
Sweetman: In terms of the council candidates who were elected, we got some new, new blood on council. How do you see yourself, l working with the new council? I know obviously you won't be on council, but in your role as an advocate.
Lovegrove: I'm seeing a tremendous number of allies on the newly elected council, who have been working with me throughout the last eight years and new ones who are incredibly close to me. I'm remarkably proud of Marnie Boers.
She is an emergency nurse. We always say if you draw a Venn diagram between Marnie and I, you, we would be drawing a circle. We're very much similar, and so I'm so proud to see her name up there, and the fact that there's nursing representation on council now, I think that is going to make a huge difference. Because she and I are advocating for the same policy changes, the same interventions, and I'm excited to have her on board so I can have that close connection to council.
Hilary Eastmure is a champion of harm reduction and a champion of the work that I've done and as well as Ben and Paul and Sheyl actually in, in the newer years. So I'm excited to keep doing what I have to do and keep working alongside these councillors to make sure that our community members stay as healthy and safe and alive as we can keep.
—
Joe Pugh: The only slate running, REAL Nanaimo, did not see any candidates elected. REAL Nanaimo council candidate Sandy Bartlett came the closest, as the second runner-up for council just under 1,500 votes away from winning a seat. In the mayoral race, REAL's Ann Marie Dryden picked up 6,084 votes. In the aftermath of the results, she hinted at running again in four years.
—
Anne Marie Dryden: We've had so many people and their families voting for us. It's hard to fathom that it turned out this way. But, , it is what it is, you know. Like, you, you have to move on. I've got four years to persuade the rest of the people that I am the one with the best resume for this job.
—
Announcer: Midcoast Morning is part of our nonprofit newsroom project supported by listeners like you. Keep this program on the air by funding it today with a monthly sustaining donation at chly.ca/donate. We've got tote bags and shirts if you need an incentive.
—
Joe Pugh: On today's program, we're bringing you into the room where Nanaimo's election results were unveiled Saturday night. Near the beginning of the night, Chief Election Officer Sheila Gurrie shed some light on what happens behind the scenes once the polls close.
—
Pugh: So the polls have now closed as we're having this conversation. What happens now?
Sheila Gurrie: What happens now is we wait for each station to enter their results, and as that happens, we'll see them up here on our screen, and once they all come in, we'll know, the preliminary results anyways that will tell us who the next mayor and council are for the city of Nanaimo.
Pugh: You mentioned preliminary results, the official results expected Wednesday. What's the difference?
Gurrie: The difference is just minor. New registrations, they bring the percentage of voter turnout down a little bit because new registrations get added to the eligible electors we started with. So that number increases, which brings the percentage of turnout down a bit, and we just verify all the results that are coming in at all the locations.
I have to go through those and verify they're all correct.
Pugh: How do we count up the votes here in Nanaimo?
Gurrie: So we use vote tabulators, which is very common throughout all the municipalities here in B.C. that I know of, and the provincial elections have used them as well now too. So they count the ballots for us.
They run result tapes at the end of the night, and then we enter those results into our system, which then show up here on our screen, and that's how we get the results. So verifying them for the final results on Wednesday is just me verifying that those numbers have been entered correctly from the tapes that we receive from the voting tabulators.
Pugh: And what is this day like for you personally?
Gurrie: It's crazy. So it's very busy with this many locations. We have great staff that have been trained exceptionally well, and they're in charge of each of their locations. So my job really is to just support them in any way I can, so I go up and down, to all the 10 locations.
I don't get over to Protection Island. They're open 10 to 6 on General Voting Day. But I go up and down Nanaimo at all the locations, make sure they have the support they need, the supplies they need, [and] answer any tough questions that come into headquarters.
Pugh: And so once we see the results, when do the people who get elected, when do they become the new council and mayor?
Gurrie: So yes, that's a good question because the current council will remain council officially until immediately before the new council is sworn in, and that will happen November 9th. So November 9th here in this room, we'll have the inaugural council meeting for the next council, and they'll get sworn in that night.
—
Pugh: Incumbent Councillor Ben Geselbrecht took home the most votes. He spoke with CHLY political reporter Mick Sweetman.
—
Mick Sweetman: It looks at this point like the council may be becoming, like, a little more progressive in its makeup. Like, how do you see kind of working, with that future council and kinda, like, how, you know, that might shift some of the dynamics?
Ben Geselbracht: You know, I think that really, [in] municipal politics, we're really focusing on, challenges on the ground, and it looks like a very strong crew of rational, hardworking people that will be listening hard to the community and putting the community's interests first. And so I really see, um, just a really effective group of people, um, in terms of addressing all the things that pop up, and I think that we've got a really good shot of making a dent in some of the challenges that we've been facing around, housing affordability and building more non-market housing.
You know, providing good services, to help folks get off the street, out of homelessness, and into housing and care, and keeping neighborhoods safe. And I think that if we really keep working all together and collaborating with all the community groups and keep that our focus, we'll be able to continue making improvements for the community.
Sweetman: And what advice do you have for the new city councillors?
Geselbracht: I think the number one thing is listen to the community, do your homework, and show up with a smile on your face 'cause there's a lot of challenges that come, and just gotta keep a positive attitude and do your best.
Sweetman: Do you have any priorities that you're really looking to, to get active on this term?
Geselbracht: Absolutely. Um, you know, number one thing has been to look at how to build non-market housing at scale. We already have a pilot program that's been initiated at council, and so I would like to see that through and begin working on a bunch of pilot, buildings, bringing in lower cost financing, building innovation, bringing in, you know, building a community land bank and also the non-profit, community service providers to provide, yeah, low-cost housing for workers, seniors, people with disabilities, young families.
And then I really want to keep working [on] the problem of helping folks that are living in homelessness get off the street into housing and care and keeping our neighborhoods safe. And then, I think really putting focus on economic development, the easy– not the easy things, but the little thing that we can really do is speeding up our permitting processes.
I'd like some focus on that and working with the prosperity corporation and bringing in the different industries of the future that we need to support our local economy. And getting that new hospital tower and cath lab is gonna be a number one priority at the regional district of Nanaimo, and we've already been saving a ton of money for that and really pushing the province hard.
And we're just gonna keep the pedal to the metal on that, 'cause those healthcare services are so badly needed in the community, and people in this community aren't getting the care that they need. And finally, just keep focused on providing effective, accountable government and listening to the community.
I think when we listen close to the community, we can't go wrong, and that should be our number one priority.
—
Joe Pugh: Andréa Coutu claimed a spot on council after running a thorough campaign. She arrived at the auditorium as the final polls were coming in and was still processing the result when she spoke with show executive producer Jesse Woodward.
Andéa Coutu: It's a, it's a bit of a shock. When I left, there were only 70% of polls in. So there's been a little bit of movement. So I'm still kind of processing that. I'm, ... A lot of people have helped me. You know, Janice Perino was really welcoming, and I see her just, just not quite on the board. And it's a lot to process honestly.
There's a lot of people who've run really strong campaigns. But I'm excited as well. It's... I've got a lot, a lot of different thoughts and emotions going through me right now.
—
Joe Pugh: Nurse Marnie Boers is the other newcomer to council. She spoke with reporters near the end of the night.
—
Mick Sweetman: How are you feeling kind of at the results that you're seeing right now
Marnie Boers: As they come in? I feel good about things right this moment. But I still have, I think there's still two more polls, so I don't wanna get too excited. But yeah ... I feel pretty good about it. It looks like there's a pretty good gap now between me and number nine.
Sweetman: And, how do you feel your campaign went? When you were kind of out there campaigning, how, what was your response that you were getting?
Boers: You know, I worked really hard. I was still working as a nurse, and I was finishing my masters, and I definitely hit the ground running and did quite a bit of events. I was at Island Roots and did the Lantern Festival and got out in front of the community as much as I could.
I felt like people wanted to hear what I had to say, and they related to me and they wanna see a, you know, that kind of healthcare proactive upstream approach, and I'm looking forward [to] hopefully to be able to get some things done on city council.
Sweetman: As a new city councillor, what are the first things that you'll be doing, should these, should these results hold, of course?
Boers: Of course. Um, I guess just settling into a new role and seeing who else will be on city council and go from there.
Sweetman: Do you have any priorities that you're really looking forward to work[ing] on?
Boers: Well, certainly the drop-in centres, which I mentioned quite a few times through my campaign. Just trying to get a space because I know there's some money still out there for the hub.
So if we can try to mobilize that and get some, especially before winter, to get multiple drop-in spaces throughout Nanaimo, I think that would be ideal. Um, and try to see if we can make a difference within our unhoused population, for sure.
—
Joe Pugh: It was mentioned that turnout was up over the last local election, with 31% of eligible voters casting a ballot, compared to around 24% in 2022.
Returning Councillor Sheryl Armstrong was pleased to hear about the increased turnout and said she was looking forward to working with the next council.
—
Sheryl Armstrong: I think that's excellent. We need to get people out and vote. Like, people are always complaining. You can't complain if you don't vote. I mean, we're lucky to live in a country where we can vote, and I just wish more people would.
And I don't think people realize the most significant level of government for you, for the most part, your municipal government. They provide your services that you need, and you need to get out and vote. I look forward– I look forward to working with everybody. I think there's a good crew at the table, and I think it'll be good. Five women!
Jesse Woodward: Congratulations!
Armstrong: Thank you!
—
Joe Pugh: Nanaimo's longest serving councillor claimed the eighth and final spot on council. Here's Ian Thorpe speaking about his re-election.
—
Joe Pugh: Can you take me through what this night has been like for you?
Ian Thorpe: Oh, it's been extremely interesting, as we knew it would be. There's always surprises. I'm really, personally, very grateful to be re-elected again, if indeed the numbers hold up. There's some good new faces on council and some good returnees. So we'll hopefully be a group that can work well together.
Pugh: What are you hoping to see council achieve over the next four years?
Thorpe: I think we need to really work on our economic development for the city and make sure that we're growing our tax base. We hear about tax numbers and people want to see some relief in that area, and one way that we can do that is to attract more business.
Pugh: And we've been here with results filtering in for more than an hour, kinda one poll at a time. Can you just tell me a bit about what that experience has been like as a candidate in the race?
Thorpe: Oh, well, it's as I said, been extremely interesting, and I came here tonight not knowing what to expect. There's always some surprises, and it's just very interesting. I do feel badly for candidates that put a lot of work into their campaigns and have not got the results that they were hoping for.
It's hard, especially for first-time candidates. So I hope they'll try again in future.
Pugh: This is, you've been on the council since 2014. How does this election night compare to the other ones for you?
Ian Thorpe: I'd say very similar, really. There's usually a balance of mainly incumbents and a few new faces, and that's always healthy. As somebody who's been around the table for a while, I look forward to helping, mentor[ing] some of the new people.
Joe Pugh: Well, thanks for the time, and congratulations on what looks like your re-election.
Ian Thorpe: Thank you very much. Appreciate it.
—
Joe Pugh: Councillor and former MP Paul Manley had the second-most votes on the night.
He said the result brought his election win percentage to 500 in what was his eighth campaign. He spoke about some of the issues Nanaimo is facing over the next four years.
—
Paul Manly: We have a lot of work to do. I mean, this city is a fast-growing community, and we're experiencing a lot of growth pains. And we have a lot of aging infrastructure, so, you know, nobody likes raising taxes, but we have to do things like we're changing out the force main for the 75% of our sewage goes through from Departure Bay out to the sewer control, the pollution control center, and that's an expensive project.
We have to deal with our hospital, which is overcrowded. We need a lot of affordable housing in this community. So there's just a lot of challenges. We have to work on densifying in areas that make sense, so that's why … following the official community plan with secondary urban cores makes a lot of sense. So we're not spreading the city out like it has been in the past, because a spread out city is an expensive city!
—
Joe Pugh: Nanaimo's next council will be sworn in ahead of their first meeting November 9th.
—
That's our show for the day. Thank you for joining me. I'm Joe Pugh, host and producer of Midcoast Morning. Additional help with this episode was provided by Mick Sweetman, Luis Zablah, and Jesse Woodward, who is our executive producer. Also thanks to Arbie Frue, our technical advisor. You can sign up for CHLY's newsletter at chly.ca/subscribe.
You can also get in touch with us at news@chly.ca. Our theme song is First One by local Nanaimo band Waste Management. Reporting in this story was produced with funding support from the Local Journalism Initiative administered by the Community Radio Fund of Canada. That's all for now. I'll talk to you on another Midcoast Morning.
—
Announcer: This program gives thanks to the Snuneymuxw First Nation as we broadcast and podcast from their traditional territory. Thanks for listening!
Program Notes
Guests
Leonard Krog — Mayor, City of Nanaimo.
Sarah Lovegrove — Candidate for mayor of the City of Nanaimo.
Anne Marie Dryden — Candidate for mayor of the City of Nanaimo.
Sheila Gurriet — Chief Election Officer / Director of Legislative Services, City of Nanaimo
Ben Geselbracht — Incumbent Councillor, City of Nanaimo
Andréa Coutu — Candidate for council of the City of Nanaimo.
Sheryl Amrstrong — Incumbent Councillor, City of Nanaimo
Marnie Boers — Candidate for council of the City of Nanaimo.
Ian Thorpe — Incumbent Councillor, City of Nanaimo
Program Team
Joe Pugh — Host and Producer.
Jesse Woodward — Executive Producer.
Mick Sweetman — Political Reporter.
Luis Zablah — LJI Reporter.
Arbie Fru — Technical Assistance.
Podcast Photo
Incumbent Mayor Leonard Krog watches the results come in. (Jesse Woodward / CHLY 101.7FM)
Theme Music
Funding
This program is part of our Nonprofit Newsroom Project. Sustain local news for many years to come by signing up for a monthly Sustaining Donation.